Suburban Marxist and others, in comments, rightly ask this question:
When will Grodscorp post a statement condemning the Israeli atrocities currently underway in Gaza?
And while I can’t speak for Scott, John, Ant and others, the reason I haven’t posted or commented about it is this: I’ve just run out of things to say.
For a journalist attuned to world politics to say such a thing sounds lazy and evasive; and for a blogger to toy with irrelevant bottom-feeders like MK and Dr TingTong while staying silent on Israel and Palestine seems superficial to the point of silliness. But after years of writing, ranting and fuming about the limitless hatred and senseless murder that Israelis and Palestinians visit upon each other, it feels that every time I speak up or spill ink on the matter, I’m going over ground that I and a thousand people smarter than me have covered countless times before. So now I prefer to watch, wait and hope, rather than to write, rant and revile.
Don’t mistake my silence for indifference though. I’m a lifelong follower of this crisis, born shortly before the Yom Kippur War and raised in a house where every war and wave of aggression was discussed around the dinner table or the TV. I chose to study it at university (my tutor was one of those Israel-criticising Jews that right-wing bloggers love to portray as race-traitors). I visited Israel in 1998, where I found the people wonderful but the atmosphere so tense and uncomfortable that I cut a six-week visit down to four and left despairing that a solution was a generation away.
And that, by and large, has been my position since: one of despair. I despair for that part of the world and particularly its children, whose innocence is all too brief before they are infected by the pathological contempt Israelis and Palestinians feel for each other and for peace itself. I despair for the Israeli civilians who live each day in fear of Hamas rockets dropping on their homes and schools; and I despair for those killed and maimed by ever-disproportionate IDF retaliation. I despair for the leaders – Sadat, Rabin, Peres, Clinton and others - who worked so hard to forge a brittle peace; and I despair for those who frittered it away with their stubbornness and stupidity. And I despair for the world, condemned as it is by the shockwaves that radiate from this region: the malevolent shadow of al Qaeda, the abhorrent anti-Semitism rising in the Middle East and the threat of nuclear war on Iran.
Every new wave of conflict brings little that is new, it is just the same play in the same theatre with a different cast. Writers and bloggers finger-point and fulminate but new insights and attitudes are virtually absent. For some it’s just a further opportunity to vent the frothing bile of racism they ordinarily release in just a trickle. Some scour the media and the blogosphere, cherry-picking to support their ideological position or statements they can flag as support for terrorism or war crimes. The conspiracy theories and mental gymnastics that some will use to explain or justify dispossession, violence or murder is bewildering … they will condemn Hamas for firing rockets and mortars at civilians – and in the same breath explain away the bombing of a school as a legitimate military tactic. There is no better example of this than the treatment of Rachel Corrie after she was crushed to death by an IDF bulldozer in 2003; nothing on the Internet has upset or disgusted me more than the campaign of vilification since visited upon her.
So, while others at Grods will see it differently, that is my position. I choose to say little, feeling a little guilty for doing so – but I am watching closely nonetheless.