Shock! Blue-rinses offended by Gallipoli slur
Posted by Bridgit Gread on Friday 31 October 2008, 5:27 pm Categories: Life, Media, Society, Un-Australian of the year Tags: Tags: Gallipoli, history, PaulKeating, WW1 |
Don’t the wankers in the mass media love it when someone slags off ‘Australian icons’ (TM) like Don Bradman, Steve Irwin or Gallipoli. Today it’s Paul Keating, who in his latest book points out quite correctly that the Gallipoli campaign was a disaster from whoa-to-go, and that building a national identity on it is tenuous at best. You could just sense the populists, the blind patriots and the blue-rinsed bigots queueing up 3AW talkback or tapping away madly on the Herald Sun’s comment pages. Keating: the ‘lizard of Oz’; the lover of froggy antiques and Italian suits; the man who groped Her Maj; the scumbag who gave us ‘the recession we had to have’ (as opposed to the one we’re about to) - now he’s slagging our brave Diggers.
But we all know Keating’s not slagging anyone off - save perhaps Churchill, the drunken imperialistic old toad - and that factually, he’s quite right about Gallipoli. It was a tragedy for our troops but its elevation above other battles and campaigns is illogical. It wasn’t our first war as a nation: we had close to 20,000 men serve in the Boer War, another British military fuck-up. We didn’t suffer the worst there (France lost a much higher proportion of its troops) nor is it our costliest defeat (six times as many Australians died on the Western Front - and three-quarters as many died in one day’s fighting at Fromelles as did in the entire seven months at Gallipoli). But let’s face it, the rocky beach, the high cliffs, the Muzzies with machine-guns - it all makes for a great yarn, the stuff from which national myths are woven.
None of that will matter to the Gallipophiles, however, who have spent their lives marching to the nationalist drum and getting drunk on CEW Bean or Les Carlyon. The facts of history mean little to those who just want to use it as a euphoric drug.
We were left in no doubt after his 